These days, nearly as much research and development goes into how we package our food as goes into the food itself. Innovations and high-tech solutions mean that the cartons, films and bottles ensure that the food is kept fresh and safe, helping food production to become more efficient and safe.
In Austin, Texas, there is a supermarket where customers are advised not to come empty handed to do their weekly shopping: fabric bags are the order of the day. Shoppers who fail to bring these must buy compostable containers to take home their purchases of fruit and vegetables, which are largely locally grown. Known as the first precycling supermarket in the United States, it does not offer any packaging at all.
What may work on a small scale, however, is simply inconceivable at a larger level, with food packaging now an essential part of our everyday lives. “Packaging is key when it comes to protecting our products, guaranteeing our high quality standards, preventing food waste and informing consumers,” says Dr. Anne Roulin, Global Head of Packaging and Design at Swiss food conglomerate Nestlé. There are many reasons for the growing need for food packaging. More than half of the world’s population lives in cities, where there are few options for growing food independently. The planet’s 3.5 billion city-dwellers thus buy their products outside of the home – and they usually come packaged. In addition, the rising number of single-person households, which prefer smaller portion sizes, and the growing trend of eating on the move between appointments are giving rise to an increasing amount of packaged food.
The number of metric tons of food production – around one-third of the total – lost or wasted every year worldwide.
The amount of edible food per person that is lost or wasted each year in industrialized countries.
Freshness is imperative
The demands made of packaging are high. Guaranteeing freshness and hygiene is a particular challenge, as foods must often cover great distances when travelling from their place of origin to supermarket shelves. Further time passes before they find their way into a shopping basket, and then again before they ultimately end up on the dining room table. Highly developed technology ensures packaging can keep products impeccably fresh and hygienic. A quick glance in the refrigerated section shows the complexity of what is involved – the packaging for cheese and sausages, for example, is made of a wide range of plastics. The differing characteristics of these composite materials are combined to ensure the packaging is ideally suited to the food. The base of the packaging, for example, can be produced to have different characteristics than the lid or wrapping film.
Hard-wearing composites made of various materials are also well suited for use in what is known as Modified Atmosphere Packaging or MAP. With this technology, the air surrounding an edible product is replaced with a protective atmosphere specially tailored to the food. One example is a mixture of nitrogen and carbon dioxide. These slow-reacting gases replace oxygen, and slow the growth of germs, all without using any preservatives. To ensure the solution works properly, the packaging material must form an effective gas barrier. Otherwise, the valuable protective atmosphere would quickly be lost.
"Depending on the food, packaging has to be firm, flexible, transparent, printable, or impermeable to aromas, oxygen or carbon dioxide," explains Dr. Rolf-Egbert Grützner from polyamide market development at BASF. There is no such thing as a universal material that can do it all. The bottom section of the packaging is made of plastic, such as polypropylene. Polypropylene provides flexibility, protects against moisture, and can act as a seal. The flexible, removable, and often resealable lid is made of a five- or seven-layer film. The uppermost layer contains polyamide like BASF’s Ultramid® which is particularly stable and pliable, keeps out oxygen and carbon dioxide, and retains its shape at higher temperatures. The lid ensures an extremely high puncture resistance; it prevents oxygen from entering the packaging and any fat contained within the food from going rancid, or harmful microorganisms developing.
In Japan, the development of sophisticated packaging systems is also driven by regional eating preferences. Japanese consumers react very negatively to packaging that no longer appears perfectly intact from the outside; even harmless creases or folds in packets can cause perfectly fine food to be left on the supermarket shelf. Fish and seafood are often on the menu, and it is particularly important that they are kept fresh and protected against spoiling. It is popular to package foods accompanied by small sachets filled with substances that bind moisture, such as silica gel and starch polymers. “For Japanese consumers, the presence of sachets indicates that the product is very well protected,” explains Sven Sängerlaub from the Fraunhofer Institute for Process Engineering and Packaging (IVV). In contrast, many Europeans view such tiny sachets of moisture-binders with suspicion, and their presence inside a package can prompt skepticism about the food it contains.
How can consumers accurately assess the condition of products? Uncertainty in this area often leads to waste: “Too many consumers see the best before date as an absolute cut-off point, although many foods can still be eaten after this time,” explains psychologist Stephan Grünewald, from rheingold, a German market and media analysis institute. Every year, in industrialized countries, 95 to 115 kilograms of perfectly good food is lost or wasted by each person, according to a study by the Food and Agriculture Organization of the United Nations (FAO).
In years to come, ‘intelligent’ or ‘active’ packaging could help reduce food waste. This is a response to experts’ efforts around the world to come up with new ways to inform consumers about the perishability of food and to protect against spoiling. The new systems could display the state of a product, and at the same time increase its lifespan with oxygen absorbers or special acids. As an example, American firm Sonoco is currently developing packaging with integrated microchips that collect information about the condition of a product, such as moisture and temperature. It raises the alarm when preprogrammed thresholds are exceeded or fall below target. “In the future, I expect to see a shift in business models towards direct contact with consumers,” predicts Dr. Anne Roulin from Nestlé.
Alongside freshness, increasing numbers of consumers want packaging that can be recycled. According to a survey of 6,000 consumers in ten different countries, carried out by Swedish carton manufacturer Tetra Pak, recyclable packaging is one of the public’s key priorities, as it is seen as kinder to the environment.
Consumers and legislative regulators are becoming increasingly concerned with packaging. The aim here is primarily to encourage the efficient use of resources. This trend is particularly noticeable in Europe. In the Netherlands, for example, a tax is applied to packaging manufacturers according to the average CO2 emissions of the materials used – 36 to 57 euro cents per kilogram for aluminum packaging, 6 euro cents for cardboard.
Sustainable packaging can be worthwhile for packaging manufacturers and food companies. In Europe in particular, demand is on the rise for paper and cardboard packaging with environmentally friendly recyclable fibers, which are also cost-effective. In addition, companies are working to come up with solutions that simplify packaging designs so that recycling rates rise.
Increasing recycling rates, reducing material requirements
BASF products that contribute to reaching the goals of reducing material requirements and increasing recycling rates include additives, which make plastics more elastic and resistant to ageing and tearing. They are used in processes such as recycling PET beverage bottles. Additives belonging to BASF’s Joncryl® family ensure that the recycled material obtains the quality of new PET. Moreover, paper chemicals from BASF enable the production of new paper and board from recycled fibers.
Water-based adhesives offer an alternative to traditional adhesives. They do not contain potentially harmful ingredients like solvents or aromatic amines which could migrate into the food. In addition, they help optimize production processes, as laminates made with these adhesives can be processed quickly, cutting costs and increasing flexibility. BASF recently launched the first water-based compostable adhesive, Epotal® ECO, which can be used for fully biodegradable packaging.
Recycling is one thing; there is growing demand for renewable materials that are biodegradable too. Drinks cartons or food containers, for instance, can be made of biodegradable plastics formed partly of renewable raw materials. After use they can be disposed of and composted with the rest of the food waste.
There can be plenty of garbage left over after sports events, music concerts, and busy days at the zoo. To turn disposable cutlery and food packaging into valuable compost, BASF has developed biodegradable plastics based on renewable materials. The product ecovio® has been available since 2006, and is made of ecoflex®, a biodegradable plastic, and polylactic acid derived from the renewable raw material corn (maize). Due to its molecular structure, ecovio breaks down in a similar way to organic waste, as microorganisms decompose the plastic with the help of enzymes.
The material ecovio® can be used, for example, in biodegradable garbage can liners, shopping bags, cup coatings, and food containers made of foam. It is particularly well suited for use in what are known as closed-loop systems – closed waste systems that can be set up in stadiums, hotels and businesses. Here, the operator will exclusively provide visitors with compostable food serving items. After use, this packaging is mixed with leftover food and collected in organic waste disposal units. A special waste disposal firm then empties these units, and transports the garbage to a composting facility. This ensures far fewer extraneous materials make it into the facility, which would otherwise have to be carefully removed. The Seattle Mariners baseball club is one of the first organizations to apply this system. Around 80% of waste generated during one of the team’s home games is sent for composting.
Reducing the weight of packaging is another way of protecting the environment while protecting companies’ bottom lines. As well as cutting the CO2 emissions generated during transportation, making packaging lighter can reduce costs too. Corrugated cardboard, frequently used in transport packaging for food, can be reduced in weight with the help of fluid synthetic dry strength agents. These mean that fewer paper fibers are needed to construct the cardboard, without compromising its strength.
BASF has managed to develop a system, based upon the innovative product class polyvinyl amine, which enables paper producers to respond to the fluctuating quality of their raw materials. The trick is to combine an anionic and a cationic polyvinyl amine. This improves the mechanical strength of the packaging paper, allowing its weight to be reduced while maintaining the same stability. BASF markets this dry strengthening system under the name Carrier System.
Focusing on health
In many countries around the world, the trend towards greater sustainability goes hand-in-hand with an enhanced awareness of personal health. As well as information about the contents, food packaging should also provide details relating to nutrition, calories, and possible allergy triggers.
Labels with the required information are applied to food packaging with the help of specifically formulated adhesives. Pressure-sensitive adhesives, which are used to produce self-adhesive labels, pose special challenges. On frozen products for example, the label must stay in place at sub-zero temperatures.
When used in the food sector, adhesives also have to comply with a range of strict regulations. “That’s why we have our raw materials for pressure-sensitive adhesives regularly tested and certified by an independent institute,” states Michael Gutsmann, who is responsible for pressure-sensitive adhesives marketing at BASF.
Potentially dangerous substances are not limited to the food, however – they can also be found at times in the packaging material itself. In 2010, researchers at the Zurich Food Safety Authority in Switzerland found that mineral oil residue contained in cardboard packaging was being transferred to foods. The main source of the problem was deemed to be ink used in newspaper printing, which found its way into the packaging via recycled paper. The residue traces detected also occasionally came from inks used to print the food packaging. These oil residues evaporate at room temperature, and can then be transferred to dry foods, such as pasta, semolina, rice, or cornflakes. This is even possible merely when the transportation packaging of the food contains recycled paper. Certain components of mineral oil are suspected of being carcinogens, according to the World Health Organization’s Joint Expert Committee on Food Additives, and the FAO.
Mineral oil barrier in packaging
Going forward, one way of reducing or even entirely eradicating mineral oil residue in paper and cardboard packaging is to use water-based binders for mineral oil-free printing of newspapers. In addition, food can be protected against the migration of unwanted substances through functional barriers.
Under the Joncryl® brand name, BASF has developed aqueous binders that national newspapers in the United Kingdom and Italy already use for mineral oil-free flexo printing. Joncryl is also ideal for printing food packaging.
Functional barrier solutions are currently available for practically all types of packaging and standard manufacturing processes. In this way, our food is reliably protected from mineral oil and other potentially critical substances.
Over the last few years, research into the best, most secure types of food packaging has made major advances. Guaranteeing safety, providing freshness, and delivering information, our food’s containers are increasingly sophisticated and play an important role in our everyday lives.
The water-based dispersion Epotal® A 816 can be used to coat films. It creates the desired barrier effect in liner bags, which are often used to package foods like cereal. Three further BASF solutions are available for the protection of food packed into cardboard.
BASF’s polyamide Ultramid®, can be applied to the inside of cartons to provide functional barrier properties. Moreover, it is suitable for usage in protective inner pouches. In addition, the biodegradable plastic ecovio® FS Paper can be used to create the functional barrier for cartons. The barrier made of ecovio FS Paper can either be applied directly to the cardboard or be added to a hybrid material along with paper or plastic, which is then used for liner bags and lamination. The product also shows improvement in cardboard stiffness and provides sealing properties.
Similarly, food packed into paper and cardboard can be protected with newly developed water-based dispersions applied onto the board. “This innovative water-based functional barrier solution will give packaging producers more flexibility in creating their end s products, whether they want to print the barrier or coat the paper or cardboard,” explains Lauren Ritacco from BASF’s Paper Chemicals division in Europe. A series of tests, carried out by the Zurich Food Safety Authority, Fraunhofer IVV and Innoform, among others, have proven the effectiveness of the four functional barrier solutions.
The mineral oil barrier protects food
Food packaging is often made of recycled paper fibers. This recycled paper packaging can contain newspaper ink, which researchers have identified as the main source of potentially harmful mineral oil residues in cartons. These oil residues evaporate at room temperature and can thus be transferred to dry foods that contain fats, such as noodles.
Mineral oil residues can migrate from:
- the inner side of contaminated primary packaging
- contaminated outer packaging, for example, corrugated board packaging used to hold products during transportation
- contaminated packages in close proximity, for example, on the supermarket shelf or in delivery trucks